Discover Our Sunset Serenity
Family Tradition
Benefit from Our Experience
Family Tradition
Vacations at Conesus Lake are a family tradition. All three of our kids – who are all now college-age – have visited the Lake each summer since they were born. Their mom has spent summers at the lake since the 1970s. Their Nana has vacationed at Conesus Lake dating back to the 1940s. This Lake is our happy place.
Until recently, when
Vacations at Conesus Lake are a family tradition. All three of our kids – who are all now college-age – have visited the Lake each summer since they were born. Their mom has spent summers at the lake since the 1970s. Their Nana has vacationed at Conesus Lake dating back to the 1940s. This Lake is our happy place.
Until recently, when we visited, we rented. When we could, we rented on McPhersons Pt, a street where members of our extended family have owned property dating to the late 1800s. Some years we rented elsewhere, on both the east and west sides of the Lake.
In 2023, we fulfilled a decades-old dream to own a house on Conesus Lake. Even better, we were able to buy a home on the Lake’s east side on McPhersons Pt. Finally, we had found our Sunset Serenity!
Our Home
Benefit from Our Experience
Family Tradition
Sunset Serenity is a 4-bedroom, 2.5 bath luxury vacation rental house originally built in the 1920s. The pet friendly house sits on Conesus Lake in the Finger Lakes with 74 feet of lake frontage.
Wake to lake views from each of the four bedrooms. End the day on the patio overlooking the lake with a spectacular sunset with a drink in ha
Sunset Serenity is a 4-bedroom, 2.5 bath luxury vacation rental house originally built in the 1920s. The pet friendly house sits on Conesus Lake in the Finger Lakes with 74 feet of lake frontage.
Wake to lake views from each of the four bedrooms. End the day on the patio overlooking the lake with a spectacular sunset with a drink in hand and a fire burning!
McPhersons Pt – described by some as “the best street on the lake” – adjoins the public boat launch and is within walking distance of a general store where you can get hot meals, groceries, beer, firewood, and much more.
We have ample flat, grassy, yard space where you can lounge or play games with the family. You can also watch the kids play games from a covered porch with comfortable seating.
The lake-facing patio facing the lake can be covered with a retractable awning for shade or shelter from the elements. We also offer access to a kayak and a movable fire pit. The house has a long dock and is minutes away from two east-side marinas where you can rent boats, tubes, and other water-sports items. Have fun swimming in the spring-fed, glacier lake, whether off our dock or a boat. Enjoy fishing year-round. The lake is teeming with Northern Pike, Bass, and Walleye -- and it regularly hosts fishing competitions.
We have decorated the house with some of our favorite pictures from our Conesus Lake vacations over the years, including – especially – pictures of the many beautiful sunsets we’ve had the privilege to watch. Two of our favorites have been blown up as canvas prints that we’ve hung on the first floor. Almost all of the other sunset pictures you see are ones we took of Conesus Lake or other lakes we’ve visited. We hope you enjoy them.
Lastly, some good news for animal lovers: we are a pet-friendly house, so feel free to bring your four-legged family members along.
Benefit from Our Experience
Benefit from Our Experience
Benefit from Our Experience
Because we've rented on Conesus Lake for so many years, we have an appreciation for what makes a great rental experience. In preparing our home to welcome you, we've asked ourselves, "If we were renting this house, what kinds of things would we want to see and experience?" What kitchen items would we want to find? What would make the h
Because we've rented on Conesus Lake for so many years, we have an appreciation for what makes a great rental experience. In preparing our home to welcome you, we've asked ourselves, "If we were renting this house, what kinds of things would we want to see and experience?" What kitchen items would we want to find? What would make the house more comfortable for a large group? How would we want the kitchen stocked? What about the larger lake community would we want to know? Which local restaurants are best for young kids? Where can I rent a boat? What fun things are there to do, not just at the lake, but in the surrounding area?
We are so excited to share our home with you so that you can experience the magic of this place for yourself. Our mission is to provide our guests with an unforgettable vacation experience.
